Review: Search, Source Roles and Productive Discussion
Apply choose targeted search language, identify a source’s relationship to an event, avoid unacknowledged borrowing, make a constructive discussion move using supplied texts and original responses.
Bring the unit skills together
Use these 4 new cases to check your reasoning. Choices are temporary and are not saved to an account, sent to staff or recorded as school grades. Download your current review choices before leaving or reloading.
The download contains your current choices and any checked feedback. Keep the separate transfer-task work in your own document; downloading its instructions does not mark it complete.
Use the skills in a new task
Make a short complete response demonstrating the four skills in this unit. Use this supplied source sentence by Fictional Model Club: The hinge bent five times before the paper tore. Make an exact quotation with credit and a genuine paraphrase with credit. Propose a focused follow-up question and script a four-turn discussion using clarification, extension, evidence-based challenge and summary. Longer writing targets in optional extensions can be completed in a later session.
Work on paper or in your own document. Explain the choices you made.
- Identify the question’s main topic and limiting feature. Construct the supplied focused query and check returned source titles before reading.
- Use the source’s creation role and purpose. Do not assume firsthand means complete or unbiased.
- Compare draft to the supplied source and identify how much wording or meaning is borrowed. Apply the matching treatment.
- Identify what the reply does to the earlier contribution. Use supplied evidence rather than a personal insult when challenging.
Compare with a model response
Quotation: Fictional Model Club states, "The hinge bent five times before the paper tore." Paraphrase: The club's record reports a tear after five completed bends. Follow-up: how does a cloth connection compare under the same bend rule? Four-turn discussion: JO: What does bend mean here—one fold or a fold and return? [clarification] LEA: One fold and return; building on the test, we could also compare cloth. [extension] JO: Yes, but the supplied five-bend record does not establish cloth durability or forever. [evidence-based challenge] LEA: We agree to preserve the five-bend paper result and propose a comparable cloth trial; its result remains unknown. [summary]
A different response can also meet the criteria. Compare the evidence and reasoning, rather than copying the wording.